A row of metal keys on a black background.

What’s the difference between Secrets Management and Password Vaulting?


When a client asked about the difference between secrets management and password vaulting, I realized his question was a good one. Our collective history of such a simple string of characters is one of pain, agony and frustration. There’s no simple answer to anything security related, so the secrets management vs passwords vaulting topic bears a thorough explanation. 

In the modern era, nearly everyone at some point or another has had to create a password. You’d be lying if you haven’t nearly tossed your phone or laptop through a window trying to manage or remember your password. We hate them, and yet we need them.

For personal use, one might keep a list of passwords on paper, in their notes app, or rely on one of the many vendors offering to securely store the various passwords. If someone is able to obtain your passwords, they can cause quite a ruckus, especially if Multi-Factor Authentication isn’t enabled. This risk also extends to business – as safeguarding both your personal and professional credentials is a crucial step towards protecting sensitive data.

With security incidents becoming a normal part of their day-to-day life, CISOs around the world are implementing robust measures to safeguard sensitive information. The Secrets management and password vaulting are two crucial tools in data protection, but are often misunderstood. This in-depth analysis of secrets management vs password vaulting will highlight their importance and compare functionalities.

What is Secrets Management?

Secrets management is the process of securely storing, accessing, and managing sensitive data such as API keys, passwords, tokens, and certificates. The practice of secrets management is comprehensive involving not just hardware, but strategies to protect sensitive data.This also means that secrets management can pertain to non-human identities

Key components of secrets management include secure storage, access control, rotation, and monitoring. Aspects of this can overlap with “PAM” (Privilege Access Management). Organizations are routinely challenged in their implementation of effective secrets management due to the sheer volume and diversity of secrets they handle. For organization’s in the manufacturing or health care sectors – the growing number of machine identities has become a top concern.

Benefits of Secrets Management

Organizations with effective secrets management benefit by reducing unauthorized access, centralizing management, automating processes, and ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements. 

Ensuring sensitive information remains encrypted at all times reduces the risk of unauthorized access. By centralizing secrets in a secure repository, organizations can enforce granular access controls, simplifying the management and governance of secrets. Effective secrets management solutions automate the process of secret generation, rotation, and distribution, reducing manual errors and enhancing efficiency. 

Having a better secrets management process isn’t just about protecting IP in your organization however. Compliance with regulatory requirements is also a direct benefit. Proper secrets management strategies position organizations to meet industry and regulatory compliance standards, ensuring auditable access.

What is password vaulting?

Password vaulting is a tactic within your secrets management process. It focuses on securely storing and managing passwords. A password vault is a secure digital repository that encrypts and stores passwords in a centralized location. It typically includes features like strong encryption, multi-factor authentication, and secure access controls. While password vaulting primarily focuses on password protection, it often lacks the broader functionality of secrets management solutions.

Secrets Management vs Password Vaulting

Secrets management and password vaulting share some similarities. While both secrets management and password vaulting aim to protect sensitive information, enforce access controls, and ensure secure storage, they are not the same. They have key distinct differences.

Their differences are in functionality and scope. Secrets management encompasses a broader range of sensitive data management beyond passwords, such as API keys and certificates. Password vaulting, on the other hand, focuses specifically on securely storing and managing passwords.

Secrets management solutions often provide more comprehensive security features, such as encryption at rest and in transit, while password vaulting solutions may offer more specialized password-related controls. 

Secrets management is designed to handle a wide range of secrets and integrate with various systems and platforms, while password vaulting is limited in terms of scalability and integration capabilities.

Best Practices for Secrets Management and Password Vaulting

Cloud-based secrets management solutions help organizations secure their credentials, tokens, and keys in dynamic and distributed cloud environments, enabling secure access to cloud services. Tight management in this area plays a critical role in securing privileged account credentials, reducing the risk of unauthorized access and privileged account misuse.

To maximize the effectiveness of secrets management vs password vaulting, organizations should follow these best practices:

  • Ensure strong encryption and key management practices: Implement robust encryption mechanisms and secure key management to protect secrets at all stages.
  • Regular rotation and secure storage of secrets: Enforce regular rotation of secrets and store them in secure, encrypted repositories to mitigate the risk of long-term compromise.
  • Monitoring, auditing, and access controls: Implement monitoring mechanisms to detect unauthorized access and changes to secrets. Regularly review access controls and audit logs to ensure compliance and identify potential security breaches.
  • Integration with existing systems and workflows: Integrate secrets management and password vaulting solutions with existing systems, such as identity and access management (IAM) systems, to ensure seamless workflows and reduced management overhead.

Understanding the full scope of the secrets management vs password vaulting topic is an indispensable CISO skill and ensures a comprehensive data security strategy. While both play crucial roles in protecting sensitive information, understanding their distinct functionalities and scopes prepares your infosec team, allowing you to fill critical gaps.

By prioritizing and implementing robust secrets management and password vaulting practices today, your organization will dramatically enhance your security posture, protect sensitive data, and meet regulatory requirements. As the threat landscape evolves, continuous evaluation and improvement of secrets management and password vaulting practices will remain critical for safeguarding valuable assets in the digital era.

Message from Jacob: I’ve been working with several disruptors in this space – teams who are approaching this use case in a superior way. To learn more about who’s been impressing the 3 Tree Tech team lately, message or email email me! jfriedman@3treetech.com

Jacob Friedman of 3 Tree Tech

Jacob Friedman is a Strategic Account Director at 3 Tree Tech in Portland. He enjoys researching new disruptive tech across the full stack and introducing it to tech execs across the United States. Message him right here.

Related Posts

AI to prevent call center agent burnout is backfiring.

We now know the downside of AI in call center operations. As ChatGPT...

A Microsoft PC in the process of an update
Unenforced GPOs, the gap in your armor

What is a Group Policy? It’s the method by which many IT execs...